Monster on Netflix: All Four Seasons, Ranked
Dahmer, Ed Gein, Lizzie Borden, then Menendez. I watched all four Monster seasons, a few episodes a night. Here’s how they rank, monologue naps included.

- Title
- Monster (2022–2026)
- Where to watch
- Netflix
- Cast
- Evan Peters, Niecy Nash, Cooper Koch, Javier Bardem, Charlie Hunnam, Ella Beatty, Sarah Paulson
- Directed by
- Created by Ryan Murphy & Ian Brennan
- Genre
- True crime anthology
Solid watch. Awake and engaged throughout.
Hindi ako mahilig sa true crime. Pero when Dahmer dropped on Netflix back in 2022, I pressed play a few days after it came out, and that was it. Na-hook ako.
I didn’t binge the Monster collection in one go, though. That’s not how I watch. I usually finish a season in two to three days, a few episodes a night. After Dahmer, I watched Ed Gein when it came out, then honestly forgot the whole series existed. Then the new one, Lizzie Borden, showed up on my Netflix home, I watched it, and it reminded me na hindi ko pa pala napapanood yung Menendez brothers. So that was my last one.
Four seasons, four very different experiences, all from Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan.
For someone who gets bored fast, finishing all four is already an achievement. Most episodes had me hooked. Pero let’s be real: these shows love their monologues. Yung mga mahahabang self-talk, characters explaining their feelings to themselves, slow scenes na walang nangyayari… those were pulling me straight to sleep. I kept watching, pero may mga gabi na halos pikit na ako. 😴

Here’s how I’d rank them.
🥇 #1 – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story (2022)
This is the one that started it all, and honestly, it’s still the best.

🎭 Acting & Cast. Evan Peters is terrifying here. Hindi siya yung over-the-top na kontrabida. He’s quiet, awkward, almost boring, and that’s exactly what makes it scary. Yung blank stare niya, yung paraan ng paglalakad niya, parang hindi siya umaarte. No wonder he won the Golden Globe. But the real MVP for me is Niecy Nash as Glenda Cleveland, the neighbor who kept calling the police and kept getting ignored. Ramdam mo yung frustration niya. Her Emmy was well deserved. Richard Jenkins as Lionel Dahmer also broke my heart as a dad trying to understand how he raised a monster.
🔊 Audiovisuals & Production. The whole show feels sticky and suffocating. Yung apartment pa lang, parang maaamoy mo na. Dim yellow lights, dirty walls, that awful fish tank. Hindi mo kailangan ng gore para kilabutan ka. The production design does the job.
✂️ Editing & Sequencing. It jumps around in time a lot, and there are moments na naliligaw ako kung anong taon na. But episode 6, “Silenced,” is a masterpiece. It focuses on Tony Hughes, one of the victims, and for once the story is about the person, not the killer. That episode alone is worth the whole season.
📜 Plot & Direction. What made Dahmer work is that it’s angry at the system. The police, the racism, the neighbors who were ignored. It’s not just “look at this scary man.” It asks why nobody stopped him. That’s the angle that kept me awake.
🥈 #2 – Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (2024)
My last watch, and the one I almost skipped. Buti na lang hindi. I liked it, but it also made me uncomfortable in ways I’m still thinking about.

🎭 Acting & Cast. Cooper Koch as Erik is the standout. Episode 5, “The Hurt Man,” is basically one long take of Erik telling his lawyer what happened to him, and the camera just slowly moves closer. Walang cut. Walang music. Grabe. I forgot I was watching a show. Javier Bardem as José Menendez is also scary in a completely different way from Dahmer. Loud, controlling, the kind of dad you’d never want to disappoint. Nicholas Chavez as Lyle and Chloë Sevigny as Kitty are solid too.
🔊 Audiovisuals & Production. Ibang-iba ang mood sa Dahmer. Beverly Hills mansions, 80s fashion, sunshine. It looks pretty, which makes the violence hit harder.
✂️ Editing & Sequencing. This is where it lost me a bit. It tells the story from different points of view, which I liked at first, pero ang haba. Some episodes felt like filler, and there were scenes na parang shock value lang. Nine episodes could easily have been seven.
📜 Plot & Direction. The show keeps asking: were they abused kids who snapped, or spoiled sons who wanted the money? I like that it doesn’t answer for you. But it also invents things that even people close to the case say never happened, and the real Erik Menendez publicly called it “disheartening slander.” Months later both brothers said it helped people look at their case again. So, complicated. Just like the show.
🥉 #3 – Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story (2026)
The newest one, and the one that pulled me back into the whole series.

🎭 Acting & Cast. Ella Beatty plays Lizzie, the woman accused of killing her father and stepmother with an axe back in 1892, and she’s really good at the quiet, watchful, may-binabalak type of stare. Rebecca Hall is sharp as the stepmother Abby, and Vicky Krieps gives warmth to Bridget, the family’s maid. Charlie Hunnam is back too, this time as Lizzie’s father, which was a little distracting after Ed Gein. But the scene-stealer? Sarah Paulson as Aileen Wuornos. Every time she showed up, gising na gising ako.
🔊 Audiovisuals & Production. Ang ganda ng itsura. Dark, gothic, cramped rooms, everything feels like a pressure cooker waiting to explode. Probably the best-looking season after Dahmer.
✂️ Editing & Sequencing. Eight episodes, pero parang mas mahaba. A lot of slow, talky scenes, and this is where those monologues hit me the hardest.
📜 Plot & Direction. The show goes all in on its own version of the story, especially the theory that Lizzie and Bridget were secretly together. Interesting, pero it takes a lot of liberties, and it sometimes goes for shock instead of substance. Critics weren’t kind either, and it sits at around 42% on Rotten Tomatoes. I enjoyed it more than that number, mostly because of the cast.
4️⃣ #4 – Monster: The Ed Gein Story (2025)
Sorry, Charlie Hunnam. Ito yung pinaka-hirap kong tinapos.

🎭 Acting & Cast. Charlie Hunnam really commits. Iba yung boses, iba yung tindig, unrecognizable siya. Laurie Metcalf as his mother Augusta is the most frightening person in the whole season, and Tom Hollander as Alfred Hitchcock is a fun surprise. The acting is not the problem.
🔊 Audiovisuals & Production. Cold, gray, farmhouse in the middle of nowhere. Effective, but it gets too graphic sometimes. I get that Ed Gein inspired Psycho, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre and The Silence of the Lambs, pero may mga eksena na parang gusto lang talagang mandiri ka.
✂️ Editing & Sequencing. Ang daming side stories. Hitchcock making Psycho, other killers, and a whole subplot with Ilse Koch from the Nazi camps. Some of it is interesting, but it pulls you away from Ed. Dito ako pinaka-inantok.
📜 Plot & Direction. The season tries to say something about how we, the audience, are obsessed with killers. Which is funny, because the show itself is part of that. Critics weren’t kind to it either. The idea is interesting, but it ended up messier than the man it was trying to explain.
🤔 The thing that bugs me about the whole collection
I watched all four, so I’m part of the problem, I know. But it’s worth saying: real families are still living with these stories. Families of Dahmer’s victims spoke out about being retraumatized. The Menendez family pushed back hard on Season 2. These aren’t just characters.
The best moments of the collection are when it remembers the victims, like “Silenced.” The worst are when it forgets.
Final verdict 🎬
Monster is at its best when it’s angry at the systems that let these people happen, and at its worst when it just wants to shock you. Dahmer is the must-watch. Menendez is worth it for Cooper Koch and “The Hurt Man.” Lizzie Borden is worth it for the cast, especially Sarah Paulson. Ed Gein, unless you’re a completionist like me, you can skip. Bago pa ako antukin.
The breakdown
“Dahmer is a must-watch, Menendez is worth it for Cooper Koch, Lizzie Borden for Sarah Paulson, and Ed Gein you can skip.”